Published: 313 articles

Quartet ***


Running Time: 98 mins Certificate: 12A

Synopsis In an old country house,  former opera singers live out their retirements and in harmony. But the arrival of one of the residents’ ex-wife, a diva named Jean (Maggie Smith), brings back bad memories for mild mannered Reginald (Tom Courtenay).


It has taken decades for Dustin Hoffman to finally go behind the camera to direct after several failed attempts in the past, including one incident where he was actually fired from the set. What seems strange is that an accomplished actor would tackle a slow English drama as his debut.


The story on the whole is too light with little character development for an audience to feel and respond to these characters. There is only conflict between the two main characters of Jean and Reg.  There is also the problem that there are too many secondary characters who we see from time to time, but they may as well be in the background.


Where the film adds an extra note is in the performances. Smith and Courtenay  are the  heart and soul to the piece. While Billy Connolly and Pauline Collins completely steal the show as the other members of the quartet. Connolly brings some much needed humour, most of which is ad-libbed.  Collins also brings humour and sympathy to a character who is in the early stages of dementia.


An entertaining and charming movie, but without the actual quartet would have been tuneless.


Reviewed by Paul Logan

Gangster Squad ***

Running Time: 113 mins Certificate: 15

Synopsis A group of police officers in post-war Los Angeles get together to take down Mickey Cohen (Sean Penn), the gangster that dominates the city.

The film begins in Los Angeles, four years after the end of World War 2. In the first scene, we are introduced to John O’Mara, a police seargant on a mission to destroy the local mafia boss. At first, his actions are opposed by his boss. However he is soon called upon by Chief Parker (Nick Nolte) to oversee Mickey Cohen’s downfall.

While there are some good action scenes in the film, it lacks story. The title and general plot do suggest violence is a big part of the story, however there doesn’t seem to be a lot going on apart from shooting and the rather cringe worthy sub plot involving smooth talking cop Jerry (Ryan Gosling) and the mobster’s “etiquette coach” Grace (Emma Stone).

In terms of acting, Sean Penn’s is probably the best performance. Although he does not look like the real Mickey Cohen, he adopts the mannerisms of a cold and ruthless gangster and is believable in the role. Despite only having a small role in the film, Nick Nolte also performs well. Unfortunately the rest of the cast are somewhat disappointing. With an all star cast including Josh Brolin and Ryan Gosling, the viewer would expect better performances. However Brolin’s character comes across as rather wooden and emotionless while Gosling’s appears to be nothing more than a token womaniser.

As ‘Gangster Squad’ is based on a true story, as a viewer it would be interesting to learn more about how authentic the film actually is. The accuracy of events is questionable, particularly as the film progresses. Towards the end there is a rather ludicrous scene that makes the film lose most of its credibility.

Overall ‘Gangster Squad’ is watchable but disappointing. Although the idea had the potential to be a good movie, the lack of story and mediocre performances let it down.


Reviewed by Lesley Logan



Winners & Losers of 2012



2012 overall was a better year for movies than previous years. Here is a selection of the best and worst of the year.



1. Ted: Simply one of  the funniest films to emerge from Hollywood in recent years. Seth MacFarlane took a massive gamble and it work. Rude, crude and very funny.

2. The Imposter: Disturbing and fascinating documentary about an unbelievable event.

3. Frankenweenie: Tim Burton is back on form with his most personal project.

4. The Muppets: The return of everyone’s favourite puppets was filled with nostalgia for adults with enough moments to keep the kids entertained too.

5. Room 237: A documentary with speculation and revelations about Stanley Kubrick’s classic horror, The Shining.

6. Brave: Whimsical and entertaining entry from the folk at Pixar.

7. Life of Pi: Subtle 3D and wonderful performances of an adaptation which on paper should never have worked.

8. Argo: Tense and gripping drama with great performances throughout.

9. Moonrise Kingdom: Another eccentric entry from Wes Anderson, which could be his best work to date.

10. The Dark Knight Rises: A disappointment after the fantastic The Dark Knight, but there was enough to make Nolan’s film the best superhero movie of the year  and a great end to the trilogy.


1. Tim and Eric’s Billion Dollar Movie: Just terrible. Any film that has a sequence of kids crapping into a bathtub, while some one is it for ten minutes should be avoided at all costs.

2. Piranha 3DD: The first one was so bad it was entertaining, this was just plain dreadful. Not even Gary Busy could save this mess.

3. Snow White & the Huntsman:  A case of style over substance of this fairytale bore.

4. John Carter: Andrew stanton could not carry the magic from pixar to this boring Star Wars looking sci-fi epic.

5. Cold Light of Day: Willis and Weaver must have needed the money to appear in this predictable tired thriller.

6. The Iron Lady: A fantastic performance by Streep, but this biopic lacked any details or facts about the Prime Minister’s life and concentrated more about a fictious account of old age Thatcher.

7. Man on the Ledge: Interesting concept, let down by a predictable and silly script.

8. Cabin in the Woods: Whedon may have made a fun superhero flick, but this delayed mismash of horror and comedy was overhyped, incredibly silly and just redid most things that the mediocre Scream franchise did over a decade ago.

9. Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter: Great visuals, but where’s the story?

10. The Amazing Spider-Man:  New direction, but the plot was just rehashed from the first entry.




We’re back

Sorry for the lack of posts over the last few months. It’s been a busy end of the year with getting married and graduating, but now we are back to give film reviews and movie news.

Ted *****

Running time: 106 mins Certificate: 15


Synopsis:  When Eight year-old loner John Bennett finds a stuffed bear under the Christmas tree, he wishes it would come alive.The little boy and his family are shocked when his wish comes true. 25 years later, John (Wahlberg) and Ted’s slacker antics are fast getting under the skin of John’s girlfriend (Kunis). Someone has to go, but who will it be?


After many years of doing animated television work, Seth MacFarlane makes the giant leap into the world of live action feature filmmaking. And what a debut it is. A great story, fantastic actors, impressive effects and enough risky humour to make a nun blush.  


In fact with the humour it feels very much like how good Family Guy was when it started on air over a decade ago. Since that time it has gone the way of The Simpsons and the show is not as good as it used to be. But fans of the series can rejoice as it is everything that a Stewie fanatic had hoped it would be.


The story while basic is never silly or stupid (only in humour). The audience will totally believe that the bear can walk and talk with no one taking the blind bit of notice, that a stuffed animal is doing everything the human’s can do. There are the usual things audiences will be familiar with Family Guy from random cameos to cutaways spoofing certain well known films. The only bad thing is the second act seems to slow the proceedings down with the romance storyline, but it is never dull.


All the leads are perfectly cast, Mark Wahlberg proves again that he is good at doing comedy. Mila Kunis is a beautiful leading lady. Community’s Joel McHale is fantastically creepy as Kunis’ sleazy boss as is the king of creepiness himself Giovanni Ribisi who plays a demented father who wants to buy Ted for his obese son.


Not for the sensitive, but Ted is the funniest films to come out of Hollywood in years. Here’s hoping the invitable Ted 2 will be as funny and entertaining to watch.




Reviewed by Paul Logan

Revenge of the Electric Car ****

Running time: 90 mins Certificate: PG


Synopsis: Documentarian Chris Paine follows up his 2007  film Who Killed the Electric Car? with another look at the world of the automotive industry. The question remains the what is preventing the development of a mass-produced electric car?


This is the follow up to director Chris Paine’s 2006 documentary, Who Killed The Electric Car?, which showed how General Motors built prototype EV-1 electric cars – loved by drivers but which were ultimately recalled and destroyed by the company.


Paine takes his film crew behind the closed doors of Nissan, GM, the Silicon Valley start-up Tesla Motors, and an independent car converter named Greg “Gadget” Abbott to investigate the resurgence of electric cars.


An optimistic look at what was regarded by many as a dead technology due to high prices and limited interest from car buyers. Paine has picked an interesting set of people, who all have different agendas, with personalities to match. The documentary is never dull due to the excellent pacing and editing.


Although the use of celebrity interviews seems somewhat out of place. Paine seems to be more interested with famous people’s options rather than the average Joe on the street. It feels very much like a marketing ploy for the trailer rather than adding anything interesting to the conversation.


Whether audiences will agree with the filmmaker’s view, no one can deny that Paine has made another captivating and interesting film about this remarkable vehicle which has been brought back from the dead.


Reviewed by Paul Logan

Magic Mike ****

Synopsis:  When 19 year old college dropout Adam (Alex Pettyfer) moves to Tampa to live with his sister Brooke (Cody Horn), he meets “entrepreneur” Mike Lane (Channing Tatum) while working on a building site. A chance meeting between the two then results in a new career for Adam and begins Mike’s road to realising what he really wants.


The film begins when Adam (Pettyfer) and Mike (Tatum) meet on a building site. Having left the job after one day, Adam runs into Mike on a night out and persuades him to get him into a nightclub. It is revealed Mike is a stripper working alongside four other dancers for manager Dallas (Matthew McConaughey). On that night, Adam is pulled in to help with props, resulting in him getting a job with the strippers.


The film is entertaining from the beginning. However there is also a deeper storyline as the film focuses on the seedy side of Mike’s world, his desire to succeed beyond stripping and his relationships with women. Although the trailer gives the impression this is a fun film about a male stripper, there is a dark side to the story that shows how a seemingly fun and carefree career can have serious impacts on an individual’s life.


The main characters in the movie are very three-dimensional. They all have goals they want to achieve and their own issues/reasons for holding back. From desperate-to-succeed Mike to immature Adam to cautious Brooke, these characters are people the audience can identify with. While it would have been easy for a film of this nature to focus on the comic/entertainment side, well developed characters really add to the viewing experience.


Despite the darker elements, Magic Mike has a number of light hearted moments that will make the audience laugh. The soundtrack is also enjoyable and the dance routines well choreographed.
With its well written plot, three-dimensional characters and the mix of fun and real life, Magic Mike is a must see.


Reviewed by Lesley Watt

Chris Fujiwara set to be Artistic Director for EIFF for another three years

Edinburgh International Film Festival (EIFF) has announced the continuation of Artistic Director Chris Fujiwara’s tenure, initially for a further three years. The appointment was announced following 2012’s successful EIFF that saw admissions of just over 40,000 across the 12-day event.


The 66th EIFF, Fujiwara’s first Festival as Artistic Director, hosted an international programme with 120 diverse new feature films, alongside two retrospectives, shorts programmes, a full industry programme, talent development labs, education initiatives and special events. Fujiwara also oversaw the return of the Michael Powell and International Awards to the Festival, as well as high-profile red carpet premieres at Edinburgh’s Festival Theatre.


Commenting on his future at EIFF, Chris Fujiwara said: “Working on this year’s EIFF has been one of the most challenging and fulfilling experiences of my career. The interest and enthusiasm of the Festival audience and the dedication and professionalism of the Festival staff and volunteers have transformed my view of the importance cinema can hold in people’s lives. I’m deeply grateful to the Board for their confidence in me, and I’m thrilled to have the opportunity to expand our relationships with our audiences and with international filmmakers, distributors and sales agents. I’m very excited about working to shape the future of EIFF.”


On behalf of the EIFF Board which confirmed the appointment, Chair, Leslie Hills said: “EIFF is an institution with a reputation for reinvention over decades. Chris Fujiwara gave us a superb reinvention in EIFF 2012. Chris, along with the excellent support of staff and volunteers delivered, with his signature intelligence, knowledge and humour, a multi-faceted programme which engaged filmgoers and professionals, students and critics alike. We are utterly delighted that he has accepted our offer to build on this very promising first edition. “

Winners announced at Edinburgh International Film Festival awards ceremony

The 66th Edinburgh International Film Festival announced the winners of this year’s awards. The Award for Best Film in the International Feature Competition was won by HERE, THEN, which received its World Premiere at EIFF. The Jury gave a Special Mention to PAPIROSEN by Gastón Solnicki. 


The Jury citation read: “The Jury acknowledges the festival and its Artistic Director, Chris Fujiwara, for an outstanding, challenging and brave selection of films that included both fiction and documentaries and enabled us to watch the best of the world’s new cinema. Every work we had the privilege to see brought something new and extraordinary to us and choosing the best was a difficult task. After the final deliberations the jury unanimously decided to give the main prize to HERE, THEN by Mao Mao that had its World Premiere here at the EIFF. The special mention goes to the documentary PAPIROSEN by Gastón Solnicki from Argentina. PAPIROSEN is a real paradigm for why cinema remains relevant. There is beauty, pain and urgency in this film. For humanity to survive, the world must not forget. This film tells us that the greatest struggle of man is the struggle for the truth.”


Director Penny Woolcock was awarded The Michael Powell Award for Best British Feature Film  for her film ONE MILE AWAY which also received its World Premiere at the Festival.  Woolcock said: “ONE MILE AWAY is about transforming and saving lives. Winning the Michael Powell award is a tremendous boost for us to help get the film and its message out to where it needs to be in our inner cities.”


 The Jury citation read: “ONE MILE AWAY by Penny Woolcock is a brave and honest film tackling a huge problem with sensitivity and skill, not only charting the efforts to reconcile a community but also showing the great wealth of creativity that is part of that struggle. We are delighted to be able to recognise such a singular achievement.


ANDREA RISEBOROUGH and BRÍD BRENNAN jointly won Awards for Best Performance in a British Feature Film for their performances in James Marsh’s SHADOW DANCER, which had its UK Premiere last night.


In the shorts category, DINOSAUR EGGS IN THE LIVING ROOM by Rafael Urban (Brazil) won Best Film in the International Short Film Competition as voted for by Jury members Erwin Houtenbrink, Programme Consultant for the International Film Festival Bratislava, actor Ewen Bremner, and Javier Porta Fouz, Programmer of the Buenos Aires International Festival of Independent Cinema.


In addition to the Best Film in International Short Film Competition Award, the Jury also commended two other films. The first Special Mention went to CARBON, directed by Craig Webster. Picking up two awards was director Will Anderson for his film THE MAKING OF LONGBIRD for which he won both Best Film in the British Short Film Competition and The McLaren Award for New British Animation. The Jury also gave a special acting commendation to TOM PHILLIPS in FUN TIMES by Joe Carter. The Student Critics Jury Award was awarded to Jang Kun-jae’s SLEEPLESS NIGHT. 



Rock Of Ages **

Based on the broadway musical, Rock Of Ages follows Oklahoma girl Sherrie (Julianne Hough) and bartender Drew (Diego Boneta) as they chase their dreams of becoming rock stars. The film is set in Los Angeles in 1987 where the pair meet. This results in Sherrie getting a job in a rock club run by Dennis Dupree (Alec Baldwin) and his right hand man Lonny (Russell Brand). As the film progresses, we are introduced to characters such as rock star Stacee Jaxx (Tom Cruise), conservative protestor Patricia Whitmore (Catherine Zeta Jones) and journalist Constance Sack (Malin Ackerman).

The story seriously lacks and, if rated solely in terms of story, the film would be very poor. It is obvious what will happen throughout the film and there are no real surprises for the viewer. While there are some comic moments, the audience are more likely to cringe in response some of the writers’ attempts at comedy.

The acting is in the film is also sub standard. Hough and Boneta resemble characters from the TV series Glee both in sound and personality. Catherine Zeta Jones is unconvincing as the female antagonist while Russell Brand’s accent is nothing short of awful. Tom Cruise’s performance is slightly better but only just watchable.

The film’s saving grace is the music. It includes songs that were originally performed by Def Leppard, Foreigner, Journey, Poison and David Lee Roth. Some of the songs are performed well while others are performed in a cheesy manner reminiscent of Glee. However fans of 80s rock will enjoy the movie and will likely move their feet in time to the music.

Rock Of Ages is watchable based on the soundtrack but the story, characters and acting are very poor.

Reviewed by Lesley Watt